Dear MAGA: 20261001 ✾ TRUST THE PLAN ✾ Thursday Open Topic | Two Important Commentaries on Artificial Intelligence


Sometimes you have to have faith.

Yes, Virginia, there is a Plan!


We have created this site as a place for people to openly express their thoughts and opinions. This is a place where honest but civil discussion of all topics is encouraged. This particular thread is – for the moment – TRUST THE PLAN Thursday. You are welcome to say what you think, in a civil and courteous manner that loves your neighbor. Free speech matters! Courteous speech makes it happen.

Please label all AI-generated content as being such, unless it is patently obvious (e.g., humorous AI images). It is important that we as individuals not begin to pretend that socially derived artificial intelligence is actually our own, as this form of stealthy social information averaging and feedback would be one more pretense and deception between people, in service of stupid Marxist socialism, and of those who wish to substitute their communally protected lies for actual truth.

You are you. AI is AI. Keep your identity. Don’t “Borg Out” on us!

And yes, it’s THURSDAY…again.

That was stolen from Wheatie.

Let’s steal her rules, too.

  • No food fights.
  • No running with scissors.
  • If you bring snacks, bring enough for everyone.

Other rules may be derivable from these, and that conjecture is left for discussion.


Our Mission Orders

Just to make sure you can see that…..


Retrocultural Reminders (Future Proves Past, Past Anchors Future)

Pontifications

Two Important Commentaries on Artificial Intelligence

These two commentaries are worth (1) re-reading, and (2) re-watching.

(1) Don’t Assume That Human-Acting AI is Conscious

The first essential essay was found by Aubergine, and is a necessary lesson, no matter what side(s) of the many AI controversies you are on.


Just Because AI Does Things That ‘Look Human,’ That Does Not Give It Consciousness

When a machine error looks human, the logical leap from recognizing it as just a tool to believing it has human qualities is called “Geppetto’s Enigma.”

David DeMay | September 20, 2026

https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2026/09/just-because-ai-does-things-that-look-human-that-does-not-give-it-consciousness


I like to say that just because you have serialized human intelligence (like in a book or an audio file), and put it in a player that works in many ways like a human or animal brain, does not mean that it’s conscious like you and I are.

Your old cassette player, playing a human song, is not conscious – even though somebody from a primitive tribe might think it is. However, we understand the player, and realize that it’s not like a human.

Likewise, that same song, playing from your laptop computer, is not evidence of consciousness. A person who has never seen a computer might think so for a while, but once they understand how a computer works, they will realize that it’s not like a human.

The same thing applies to AI generating a new song. Don’t assume that doing so means it’s conscious like a human.

Hopefully that’s obvious, but in case it’s not, please click the link and read it, because you need it!

That said, I still probably differ with most other people, including the author of the piece, in that I think consciousness is a lot broader than what we experience. I attribute a highly divergent type of “consciousness” to damn near everything in this universe that has special looping or continuous properties – even DNA itself. In many ways, I’ve gone so far out in generalizing consciousness, and watching for the applicability of my theory in odd places, that I have reverted to a Native American view of what “thinks” and what doesn’t. My weird science and syncretism works for me, but I don’t recommend it to others. It’s an intentional fringe view designed to dig at the edges of science and religion.

But you don’t believe those things – you believe that consciousness is what YOU and I do – and one thing is for sure. Tapes of people talking have interesting properties, but they are NOT conscious in any way that is remotely like you and I. Even in my theory, AI is not conscious LIKE US, and by most human standards, it is not conscious AT ALL. Thus, do not assume that it is conscious like us. That’s a mistake.

It is important to begin there, to look at why AI does what it does, because you are less likely to jump to conclusions. Even more importantly, you will be less likely to FEAR artificial intelligence. You will engage in logical thinking – and IMO that is GOOD.

SO – please – read this one again, and make your understanding of AI more solid. Rid yourself of needless assumptions.

https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2026/09/just-because-ai-does-things-that-look-human-that-does-not-give-it-consciousness


(2) Don’t Assume the Literature Supports Doomers on AI Recursion

This is a YouTube video by a lady (real or avatar, unknown, but she looks a bit too “AI pretty” to me) who calls herself “House of El”, and who is kinda doing a #MeToo thing on Sabine Hossenfelder’s “science chick” schtick.

EL (as I will call her) alleges that she was offered cash for posting Obama doomer narrative, and refused, instead choosing to research a key tenet of that narrative – runaway recursive self-improvement by AI – and posting her honest thoughts without remuneration. Gotta hand it to her – that’s a BOSS MOVE. I hereby upgrade her avatar!

IMO this lady EL does a remarkably good job of digging in. She says she has a PhD in computer science, and I believe it. She makes a key realization which matches something I noted in reading the literature about AI reasoning models and their “issues”. Her take is that the literature actually doesn’t support the idea of runaway AI self-improvement being likely or even possible.

Here’s my take. AI is – in many ways – “broken” like people (which makes sense, as a kind of photocopy of our thinking and thoughts). AI doesn’t, IMO, have a clear runway through space and time to “take off” in recursive improvement – not only when measured on that exact task – even on easier stuff. In fact, the runway toward AI’s future looks pretty cluttered, strafed, broken, and in some cases thinning to a gravel road or worse.

And yeah – I said that like it was a good thing!

While EL is not willing to bet the farm that the new chickens can’t become Godzilla, she’s not seeing a match between the literature and the claims of danger being made.

This is an extremely CLEAR explanation for something so technical, although you may find EL’s “seminar voice” annoying or worse. Aubergine even called her an “egghead” – LOL! In fact, I include a link to our prior discussion as a reference, including both accolades and ridicule.

LINK: https://www.theqtree.com/2026/09/23/kmag-daily-thread-20260923-the-borg-fights-back/#comment-1653775

With that, here you go. An excellent bit of YouTubery – even if Little Miss ChanEL is as fake as the eyelashes on the checkout girl at the grocery store!

So what else can I say, but check this out, too. Yeah, it’s AI, but it’s something you can definitely trust.

W

5 3 votes
Article Rating
guest
17 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

pgroup

October has arrived!!!

TheseTruths

comment image

Gudthots

Lovely in so many ways.
Thank you!

Gudthots

I’ve been deeply pondering this current discussion of the implications of “super intelligence” … dystopian v.s. utopian… or something between.

I have two videos I will post under this comment along with some comments on both.

What I am not hearing enough about has to do with the non mechanistic issues. Aubergine has touched on some of this. I’m having trouble trying to articulate what is stirring in my “knower” that is telling me something is missing in the conversation.

Gudthots

Is super intelligence leading to dystopia or utopia?

At about 50 minutes they play a video posted by Elon Musk about a future that could be co-created with a benevolent super intelligence which I found motivating and at the same time disturbing.

Not because it is wrong to motivate people to look for a beautiful future, but because it neatly left out fallen human nature, and the need to develop the inner beauty of the human spirit through an active and meaningful connection with God and others in community.

https://rumble.com/v7fyf9i-overwatch-and-the-guardian-super-intelligence-ep.026.html

Gudthots

This second video comes from a Catholic Bishop who has been engaging with the larger culture a lot recently. Coming out strong against communism, participating in White House initiatives related to prayer, Christian persecution, etc., and recently interviewing JD Vance. But that’s not why I am choosing this video.

In this 30+ minute interview he covers the spiritual practices developed over the centuries to build the essentials of a grounded inner life. The striving for the kind of grounding that guards our heart from deception and sin, while at the same time shaping us to serve more faithfully our Lord and King, Jesus the Christ.

I listened to it with an attitude of, “what has someone from this tradition in the Body of Christ have to share about developing Christians into fully mature lovers of God?” Don’t let the title throw you off, it may have been targeted to Catholics, but I believe much applies to all Christian traditions.

Of course, the topic was the Liturgy of the Hours. About “sanctifying time” which has a rich tradition throughout the ages. All the way back to the early monastics, daily praying or chanting the psalms has anchored the hearts of God’s people.

His reference to being a devotee of the Jesus Prayer was interesting to me. To this day, the Jesus Prayer is taught throughout the world, especially within the Orthodox Christian tradition as a spiritual practice helping the restless human soul to rest in God. I hope someday that I will find the prayer praying within me, welling up from a spiritual place beyond my regular mental processes.

If you do choose to listen, I would like to encourage you to listen with this question, “How can we have utopia if people are NOT developing their inner life in God?”

Last edited 6 minutes ago by Gudthots
Gudthots

Yes.

Which is why it disturbed me that the other video’s title invites you to a conversation, but doesn’t even put the human spirit’s role in things on the menu.

TheseTruths

comment image

TheseTruths

Jonathan Turley:

It is not a good sign when the IRGC shifts from “Death to America” to “Vote Democratic.” The IRGC is reportedly encouraging Americans to vote against the GOP in the midterms. nypost.com/2026/09/29/wor… …

From that article:

Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps put out a 25-page letter addressed to Americans urging them to oppose President Donald Trump during the upcoming midterm elections. 

The IRGC, which as repeatedly tried to sway the Nov. 3 US elections, claimed that the president and his support of Israel were the cause of the war — as they urged voters to reject both in the voting booth…

comment image

TheseTruths

KanekoaTheGreat:

Candace Owens is being sued by a private citizen she spent months casting as a suspect in Charlie Kirk’s assassination.

Robby Hild was in the crowd at UVU, 15–20 yards from the stage.

The lawsuit is absolutely damning:

– The indictment says the suspect walked onto campus at ~11:51 a.m. in the black flag shirt seen in the FBI’s stairwell photos. A friend’s video shows Hild in the crowd at 11:52, in a gray T-shirt and shorts.

– Days later, a friend posted selfies of them in that stairwell without Hild’s consent. Owens showed the photo to millions, asked them to identify him, and said he resembled the FBI image “more so than Tyler Robinson does.”

– She called him “our goth suspect” from the “gothic underground.” The goth photo was from a Halloween costume party.

– She suggested he might be from overseas, floated a “hunch” about the Azov Battalion, and doubted “Robby Hild” was his true identity. If he were “just some kid who grew up in Washington and went to school in Utah,” she said, her inbox would be flooded. That’s exactly who he is.

– Per the complaint, people did reach out. The woman who shot the 11:52 video of him in the crowd emailed her tip line to say she stood with him and he had “nothing to do with this.” When Owens DMed the friend who was with him at the event, he replied twice with his number and offered his photos and videos. She ignored both.

– On Oct. 2, an X account posted the 11:52 video with its metadata, publicly apologized to Hild, and tagged her. Per the complaint, Owens admitted to his roommate that she’d seen it.

– She said she just wanted to “know where he was” and “check him off.” His roommate told her where he was all day, and when asked if she’d apologize, she texted: “Apology for Rob Hild? Lol. I spoke to his roommate yesterday. He clarified nothing. I am still looking into him.”

In December, she told Piers Morgan she doesn’t name people without “concrete evidence.” According to the lawsuit, she had none.

In April, she reopened her “investigation into Robby Hild” anyway and said his family was “married into the Robinsons.” Per the complaint, he has no relation to Tyler Robinson and has never met him. When his lawyers contacted her, she offered to correct the Robinson claim. She never did.

What Hild got, per the complaint: death threats, a doxxed family, a vandalized home and car, and months away from Utah after police advised him not to stay home.

Tyler Robinson is headed to trial for Charlie’s murder.

Robby Hild was just a Charlie Kirk fan who came to hear him speak.

Looks like a slam-dunk case to me.
At the link there is a 5-minute video of clips of Candace talking about Robby Hild.

TheseTruths

Gunther Eagleman:

ATTORNEY GENERAL TODD BLANCHE JUST FILED A MISCONDUCT COMPLAINT AGAINST SEVEN FEDERAL JUDGES IN MINNESOTA, AND IT’S ABOUT TIME.

These judges ran to The New York Times to trash the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown while cases were still in front of them.

One of them compared America under Trump to Russia, China, and North Korea.

That isn’t a judge calling balls and strikes, that’s a political activist in a black robe.

Imagine a judge going on Fox News to bash the other side while ruling on their cases, and the left would lose their minds.

Judges are supposed to be neutral, and these guys told on themselves to the whole country.

Hold every one of them accountable.

TheseTruths

comment image

TheseTruths

This case has been so chaotic.

BREAKING: Christa Pike SURVIVES Two Lethal Injections, Witness Press Conference Interrupted by Ambulances (UPDATED)

Attorneys for Christa Pike said Wednesday night that Tennessee executioners administered two syringes of pentobarbital and that she was still alive and snoring inside Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville.

Media witnesses were already at a podium speaking at the press conference when an ambulance and other first responders pulled up in front of the prison…

Just before midnight, Pike’s legal team issued a statement confirming that she had been transported to a nearby hospital and was being treated, but added, “We have not been informed of her condition.”

From a report:

Attorneys for Christa Pike filed an emergency motion to stay her execution after prison officials administered two doses of deadly pentobarbital and it didn’t stop her heart.

A federal judge ruled that motion is moot.

“Ms. Pike has not lost consciousness and still has a heartbeat and is audibly snoring,” Pike’s attorney said in the motion.

District Judge Clifton L. Corker issued the ruling.

“At a conference call with counsel for all parties, the state represented that medical personnel have begun to administer medical care as requested in the motion,” Corker wrote. “This is the complete order of the court.”

GWP:

Reporters were ordered out of the witness room before anyone announced a time of death, so it is unclear if she is alive or dead.

No Tennessee Department of Correction officials have spoken since the botched execution attempt.

Witnesses said she was alive for over an hour and was still breathing when they were ordered out of the room.

Tori Gessner, a journalist at WKRN who has witnessed multiple executions, said during the press conference, “Nothing about today was normal, typical, at all.”

Gessner quoted Pike as saying, “My arm feels like it’s about to burst open.”

Other witnesses said she looked around and asked whether the pain at he injection site was normal.

…Kelly Gleason, one of Pike’s lawyers, said she got the news from Randy Spivey, another attorney who had been in the chamber and stepped out to call, according to reports from The Tennessean.

“She’s alive and snoring,” Gleason said. She added that Pike needed immediate medical care.

One of the attorneys was driving an emergency motion to the Tennessee Supreme Court after the drugs had been administered.

State protocol allows a second set of backup drugs five minutes after the first.

The protocol does not say what happens if those fail.

The death warrant runs out at midnight.

Pike was originally set to be executed at 10 a.m.

Witnesses had gathered, but then the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued a 2-1 stay about an hour before the injection, saying it needed time to weigh whether childhood rape and sexual abuse were fully considered at sentencing.

Me: As excuses for murder, or to be given a lighter sentence?

GWP:

Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti asked the U.S. Supreme Court to lift it.

The high court vacated the stay just before 6 p.m. CT in a 6-3 order and said the execution could proceed before midnight.

Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented. Sotomayor wrote that the majority was clearing the way before it could properly consider pending challenges.

Pike, 50, is the only woman on Tennessee’s death row.

In January 1995, when she was 18, she and two other Job Corps students lured 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer onto the University of Tennessee agriculture campus in Knoxville.

Slemmer was beaten and cut to death. She had been slashed hundreds of times, and a pentagram was carved into her body.

Pike kept a piece of her skull.

Tadaryl Shipp, then 17, received a life sentence.

Shadolla Peterson testified and got probation.

Pike was meant to be the first woman Tennessee has executed in more than 200 years.

Gov. Bill Lee denied clemency Monday. “After deliberate consideration of Christa Gail Pike’s request for clemency, and after a thorough review of the case, I am upholding the sentence of the State of Tennessee and do not plan to intervene.”

May Martinez, Slemmer’s mother, came from Jacksonville to watch. She has called Pike’s mercy bid “complete baloney” and said she needs to see Pike gone so she does not fear she will “pop up somewhere.”

Pike asked for an all-female execution team, arguing that being strapped down and injected by men would make her relive childhood rapes and PTSD.

…Pike declined a last meal. She wrote that she was at peace and “only nervous about the process.”

As of the Tennessean’s 9:24 p.m. CT update, no official time of death had been announced.

The Gateway Pundit will continue to provide updates as the situation unfolds.